关于vba：是否有一个快速排序例程而不调用自身/不使用递归


Is there a quicksort routine without calling itself / without using recursion

众所周知的quicksort例程最后使用两个递归调用。 但是，由于许多递归调用，在Excel-VBA中对大型未排序数组(> 40万个元素)使用quicksort例程可能会导致内存堆栈溢出。

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
Public Sub dQsort(List() As Double, ByVal min As Long, ByVal max As Long)
    Dim med_value As Double
    Dim hi As Long
    Dim lo As Long
    Dim i As Long

    ' If min >= max, the list contains 0 or 1 items so it is sorted.
    If min >= max Then GoTo ErrorExit
    ' Pick the dividing value.
    i = (max + min + 1) / 2
    med_value = List(i)
    ' Swap it to the front.
    List(i) = List(min)
    lo = min
    hi = max

    Do
        ' Look down from hi for a value < med_value.
        Do While List(hi) >= med_value
            hi = hi - 1
            If hi <= lo Then Exit Do
        Loop
        If hi <= lo Then
            List(lo) = med_value
            Exit Do
        End If
        ' Swap the lo and hi values.
        List(lo) = List(hi)
        ' Look up from lo for a value >= med_value.
        lo = lo + 1
        Do While List(lo) < med_value
            lo = lo + 1
            If lo >= hi Then Exit Do
        Loop
        If lo >= hi Then
            lo = hi
            List(hi) = med_value
            Exit Do
        End If
        ' Swap the lo and hi values.
        List(hi) = List(lo)
    Loop

    ' Sort the two sublists.
    dQsort List(), min, lo - 1  ' Recursive call which I would like to avoid
    dQsort List(), lo + 1, max  ' Recursive call which I would like to avoid

End Sub

我的问题是：谁知道经过修改的quicksort例程与传统的quicksort例程相比仅会花费很少的时间(由于提到的内存堆栈溢出，您只能在" old"和" new"例程之间进行比较，以便相对较小) 未排序的数组)？

针对"可能已经有您的答案的问题"显示的答案不是我的问题的答案。

相关讨论

这是双打的简单排序：

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
Public Sub aSort(ByRef InOut)

    Dim i As Long, J As Long, Low As Long
    Dim Hi As Long, Temp As Variant

    Low = LBound(InOut)
    Hi = UBound(InOut)

    J = (Hi - Low + 1) \ 2
    Do While J > 0
        For i = Low To Hi - J
          If InOut(i) > InOut(i + J) Then
            Temp = InOut(i)
            InOut(i) = InOut(i + J)
            InOut(i + J) = Temp
          End If
        Next i
        For i = Hi - J To Low Step -1
          If InOut(i) > InOut(i + J) Then
            Temp = InOut(i)
            InOut(i) = InOut(i + J)
            InOut(i + J) = Temp
          End If
        Next i
        J = J \ 2
    Loop
End Sub

Sub MAIN()
    Dim ary(1 To 3) As Double, msg As String
    Dim i As Long

    ary(1) = 0.4
    ary(2) = 0.1
    ary(3) = 0.5

    Call aSort(ary)

    msg =""
    For i = 1 To 3
         msg = msg & ary(i) & vbCrLf
    Next i

    MsgBox msg
End Sub

我不知道它是否足够"快速"。

enter image description here

提到的合并排序与传统的Quicksort具有相同的缺点：它还使用了递归调用(请参阅下面的Excel VBA代码，改编自命名的Wiki页)。 TopDownMergeSort仅对n-1个数组值进行排序。 因此，您需要在已排序的数组中插入第n个值(当然在正确的位置)。

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
Sub Test_Method_MergeSort()

    'Array adData with Doubles, starting from index = 1
    Call TopDownMergeSort(adData)
    Call InsertIntoSortedArray(adData, adData(UBound(adData)), 1, False)

End Sub

'// Array A[] has the items to sort; array B[] is a work array.
Sub TopDownMergeSort(ByRef A() As Double)
    Dim B() As Double
    Dim n As Long
    Dim i As Long

    '// duplicate array A[] into B[]
    n = UBound(A)
    ReDim B(n)

    For i = 1 To n
        B(i) = A(i)
    Next i

    '// sort data from B[] into A[]
    TopDownSplitMerge B, 1, n, A

End Sub

'Sort the given run of array A[] using array B[] as a source.
'iBegin is inclusive; iEnd is exclusive (A[iEnd] is not in the set).

Sub TopDownSplitMerge(ByRef B() As Double, ByVal iBegin As Long, ByVal iEnd As Long, ByRef A() As Double)
    Dim iMiddle As Long
    Dim dTmp As Double

    If (iEnd - iBegin) < 2 Then Exit Sub '  // if run size == 1

    '// split the run longer than 1 item into halves
    iMiddle = (iEnd + iBegin) / 2   '// iMiddle = mid point

    '// recursively sort both runs from array A[] into B[]
    TopDownSplitMerge A, iBegin, iMiddle, B   '// sort the left run
    TopDownSplitMerge A, iMiddle, iEnd, B    '// sort the right run

    '// merge the resulting runs from array B[] into A[]
    TopDownMerge B, iBegin, iMiddle, iEnd, A

End Sub

'// Left source half is A[ iBegin:iMiddle-1].
'// Right source half is A[iMiddle:iEnd-1].
'// Result is B[ iBegin:iEnd-1].
Sub TopDownMerge(ByRef A() As Double, ByVal iBegin As Long, ByVal iMiddle As Long, ByVal iEnd As Long, ByRef B() As Double)
    Dim i As Long
    Dim j As Long
    Dim k As Long

    i = iBegin
    j = iMiddle

    '// While there are elements in the left or right runs...
    For k = iBegin To iEnd - 1

        '// If left run head exists and is <= existing right run head.
        If ((i < iMiddle) And ((j >= iEnd) Or (A(i) <= A(j)))) Then
            B(k) = A(i)
            i = i + 1

        Else
            B(k) = A(j)
            j = j + 1

        End If

    Next k
End Sub

Sub InsertIntoSortedArray(ByRef dSortedArray() As Double, ByVal dNewValue As Double, ByVal LowerBound As Long, Optional ByVal RedimNeeded As Boolean = False)    ', xi As Long) As Long
    Dim n As Long, ii As Long

    n = UBound(dSortedArray)
    If RedimNeeded Then
        ReDim Preserve dSortedArray(n + 1)

    Else
        n = n - 1

    End If

    ii = n + 1
    Do Until dSortedArray(ii - 1) <= dNewValue Or ii < (LowerBound + 1)
        dSortedArray(ii) = dSortedArray(ii - 1)
        ii = ii - 1
    Loop
    dSortedArray(ii) = dNewValue

End Sub

我正在寻找的解决方案没有任何递归调用。 在排序步骤中，为了实现必要的管理目的，还添加了一些其他变量，从而成功完成了以下替代快速排序" IAMWW_QSort"：

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160
161
162
163
' This code belongs to one and the same Excel’s  code module
Private Const msMODULE As String ="M_QSort"

Private alMin() As Long
Private alMax() As Long
Private abTopDownReady() As Boolean
Private aiTopDownIndex() As Integer  ' 1 (= TopList) or 2 ( = DownList)
Private alParentIndex() As Long

Sub IAMWW_Qsort(ByRef List() As Double, ByVal Min As Long, ByVal Max As Long)
    Dim med_value As Double
    Dim hi As Long
    Dim lo As Long
    Dim i As Long

    Dim l_List As Long

    ' If min >= max, the list contains 0 or 1 items so it is sorted.
    If Min >= Max Then GoTo ExitPoint

    Call Init(l_List, Min, Max)

Start:

    If abTopDownReady(l_List, 1) And abTopDownReady(l_List, 2) Then
        abTopDownReady(alParentIndex(l_List), aiTopDownIndex(l_List)) = True

        l_List = l_List - 1
        If l_List >= 0 Then
            GoTo Start

        Else
            ' Ready/list is sorted
            GoTo ExitPoint

        End If

    End If

    Min = alMin(l_List)
    Max = alMax(l_List)

    ' -----------------------------------
    ' The traditional part of QuickSort

    ' Pick the dividing value.
    i = (Max + Min + 1) / 2
    med_value = List(i)
    ' Swap it to the front.
    List(i) = List(Min)
    lo = Min
    hi = Max

    Do
        ' Look down from hi for a value < med_value.
        Do While List(hi) >= med_value
           hi = hi - 1
           If hi <= lo Then Exit Do
        Loop
        If hi <= lo Then
            List(lo) = med_value
            Exit Do
        End If
        ' Swap the lo and hi values.
        List(lo) = List(hi)
        ' Look up from lo for a value >= med_value.
        lo = lo + 1
        Do While List(lo) < med_value
            lo = lo + 1
            If lo >= hi Then Exit Do
        Loop
        If lo >= hi Then
           lo = hi
            List(hi) = med_value
            Exit Do
        End If
        ' Swap the lo and hi values.
        List(hi) = List(lo)
    Loop

    ' End of the traditional part of QuickSort
    ' -----------------------------------------

    If Max > (lo + 1) Then
        ' top part as a new sublist
        l_List = l_List + 1
        Init_NewSubList l_List, l_List - 1, 1, lo + 1, Max

        If (lo - 1) > Min Then
            ' down part as a new sublist
            l_List = l_List + 1
            Init_NewSubList l_List, l_List - 2, 2, Min, lo - 1

        Else
            ' down part (=2) is sorted/ready
        abTopDownReady(l_List - 1, 2) = True

        End If


    ElseIf (lo - 1) > Min Then
        ' Top part is sorted/ready...
        abTopDownReady(l_List, 1) = True

        ' ... and down part is a new sublist.
        l_List = l_List + 1
        Init_NewSubList l_List, l_List - 1, 2, Min, lo - 1

    Else
        ' Both the top (=1) and down part (=2) are sorted/ready ...
        abTopDownReady(l_List, 1) = True
        abTopDownReady(l_List, 2) = True

        ' ... and therefore, the parent (sub)list is also sorted/ready ...
        abTopDownReady(alParentIndex(l_List), aiTopDownIndex(l_List)) = True

        ' ... and continue with the before last created new sublist.
        l_List = l_List - 1

    End If

    If l_List >= 0 Then GoTo Start    

ExitPoint:

End Sub

Private Sub Init_NewSubList(ByVal Nr As Long, ByVal Nr_Parent As Long, ByVal iTopDownIndex As Integer, ByVal Min As Long, ByVal Max As Long)

    ' Nr = number of new sublist
    ' Nr_Parent = the parent's list number of the new sublist
    ' iTopDownIndex = index for top (=1) or down part (=2) sublist


    aiTopDownIndex(Nr) = iTopDownIndex  '= 2 ' new sub list is a down part sublist
    alParentIndex(Nr) = Nr_Parent  'l_List - 2
    abTopDownReady(Nr, 1) = False 'The new sublist has a top part sublist, not ready yet
    abTopDownReady(Nr, 2) = False 'The new sublist has a down part sublist, not ready yet

    ' min and max values of the new sublist
    alMin(Nr) = Min
    alMax(Nr) = Max 'lo - 1

End Sub

Private Sub Init(ByRef Nr As Long, ByVal Min As Long, ByVal Max As Long)
    Dim lArraySize As Long

    lArraySize = Max - Min + 1

    ReDim alMin(lArraySize)
    ReDim alMax(lArraySize)
    ReDim abTopDownReady(lArraySize, 2)
    ReDim aiTopDownIndex(lArraySize)
    ReDim alParentIndex(lArraySize)

    Nr = 0
    alMin(Nr) = Min
    alMax(Nr) = Max

    aiTopDownIndex(0) = 2        ' Initial list is assumed to be a down part (= 2)

End Sub

由于附加的管理代码行而导致的额外时间损失很小。